Allen
Greenspan once coined the phrase “irrational exuberance” about the 1990s
stock market rise. The opposite can be said about the current stock market
and the economy. I call it irrational despair.
No, I’m not trying to be
a “bag of downers,” as my old friend John Houlihan used to quip. To the
contrary, I’m trying to give us some realistic guideposts.
Think about this. Just as
we once thought real estate prices could never stop rising, we now believe
they can’t stop falling.
We’re like my new puppy;
his name is Nike. He’s a six months old Malti-Poo. (I call him a six month
old multi-poop.) When we leave him in his kennel to go to work, he yelps and
cries. We come home a few hours later — every time. Yet, the next time we
leave he still cries and yelps like he’ll never see us again. He is so
frightened he can’t remember.
The economy will come
home. The fundamentals are there: only five percent of the work force is
unemployed; and productivity is still up.
Sure, the economy stinks
right now. Nothing lasts. The credit markets have everyone wondering where’s
the capital to get business activity moving again. I’ve spoken to people who
have jobs, credit, and cash who can’t get mortgages or business loans. The
truth is no one wants to lend to anyone right now.
Well, what did you think
after the bender we just went on? After a night of heavy drinking would you
guzzle a bottle of scotch when you first wake-up? We were giving mortgages
to people who couldn’t afford a porch. We were like the bartender who gets
paid by the glass he pours. The credit markets and their investors are not
just hung-over; they’re going through the D-Ts and the dry heaves. Give them
time. They’ll be back.
The problem is not
necessarily the mortgage-back securities that are so under scrutiny.
Sure, they did their damage. But these instruments are great ideas. They
offered more chance at home ownership by spreading the risk. The problem was
the lack of oversight by government and industry.
The Economist had a great
piece on this. There are lessons to learn the next time. And trust me; the
next time the credit market comes back they will be guarded. In other words,
to get a loan be prepared for the equivalent of a colonoscopy.
Until then, it seems the
credit market is refusing to partake in any sustenance whether it’s booze or
just plain old water. At some point, they have to take some nourishment.
Things will improve. Sure, the government may have to step in and offer
mortgage relief. Right now, a recession is far worse than inflation or
government over-spending.
Also, look at the price
of oil. It’s still around $100 a barrel. That’s horrible, yes. But wouldn’t
you
think if we’re in a recession (who knows?) that the price of oil would start
dropping? Surely it would go down to $80 a barrel. But no, it hasn’t. That
means two things: first, there is some economic activity happening around
the world to keep the price up; or two, the price of oil is not coming down.
I think it’s both.
Here’s why. Despite all
the hatred we have toward OPEC, there is only so much the oil ministers can
do to drop the price of oil. Increasing production will only drop the price
so much. The problem is this: the worldwide demand for oil from China and
India will keep oil prices high. The only way prices go down is by reducing
demand. And we are doing very little here.
We have to do one of
these three things: 1.) stop driving our cars; 2.) raise gas prices by an
additional $1 a gallon and use those revenues to find alternative sources;
3.) start drilling in the United States including ANWAR, the Gulf of Mexico,
and start producing oil from shale in the Mountain West.
If we don’t do one of
these three things, then let’s stop complaining about oil prices. If we want
our economy to continue pumping, then we need to sacrifice our pristine
lands – not the coast lines and mountains of Third World countries.
I’m as much an
environmentalist as the rest of you. But I’m also a realist. And to stop
drilling in our backyards is arrogant.
So despite this despair
there is something we can do about it. And guess what? We’re going to have a
new president and a new Congress. Gulp.
I’ll have more on that
not so irrational despair in the next post.