This is
a posting on the semantics of whether we’re in a Recession or not and
remembering a tune from the 1970s even more applicable today.
Who
cares? Either way, a Recession or downturn stinks for most of us.
But
apparently the government is fudging the numbers to keep us thinking it’s not
that bad. Investment expert John Mauldin says the government numbers about last
month’s slight economic growth don’t add up. In fact, he thinks the economy may
have actually dropped in the last two quarters.
Special
thanks to good friend Bill Bailey for directing me to Mauldin’s site.
Yes, I
know you’re shocked this Administration might fudge numbers or facts. The lack
of candor from this White House is an issue. But that’s not my point here.
We don’t
need the government to tell us whether we’re in a recession or not. We know it –
whatever you want to call it.
Ronald
Reagan, on the campaign trail in 1980, twisted economic fact into a brilliant
campaign speech. He said, “A Recession is when your neighbor loses his job. A
Depression is when you lose your job. And a recovery is when Jimmy Carter loses
his job.”
Alan
Greenspan tells the story in his autobiography. As an economist, he cringed.
Yet, he gave Reagan great credit for touching the nerve of the people.
No one
today, except maybe Barack Obama, is hitting that kind of a nerve with people.
The political campaigns and the media are too caught up in the minutia of
economics as compared to solid economic theory.
We’re
trying to figure out if two quarters with negative GDP is a Recession while
folks are losing jobs and health care.
I blame
the media and the political parties. They should be blowing-up and destroying
the silly economic notions on the campaign trail.
I don’t
know which silly notion is worse. You tell me. The first is this one. Tax breaks
should be continued even as we go into further debt and we face a looming
disaster
with Social Security and Medicare. My take: Tax breaks are fine if there’s
spending cuts and if the tax cuts spur economic growth.
The
second is the gas tax holiday. That will only spur more demand for gas and raise
prices further. Here’s the No BS on gas prices. The liberals and the
conservatives are equally at fault. The liberals stop drilling and refineries in
America. That reduces supply. The conservatives lobbied and paid off politicians
to keep oil and car companies from finding new sources of energy.
Remember
the 1970s song by Stealer’s Wheel? That’s how I feel. Stuck in the middle with
you. In case you’re too fried from the past, the rest of the lyrics are:
Clowns
to the left of me, jokers to the right,
Here I
am stuck in the middle with you.
But let
me give you a little lift.
First,
there is the theory of creative destruction from Joseph Schumpeter. Frankly, a
Recession might be needed to clear out the bad stuff. This downturn has wiped
out some lousy mortgage folks.
Second,
there is a great saying from Dick Hoey, the Senior Economist for BNY Mellon. I
used this before, but it bears repeating. Dick told me and a group of folks that
a Recession is like a hangover. You tell yourself two false things. One, you
think you’re going to die. And two, you can do something right now to make it go
away.
Hang in
there and don’t listen too carefully to the economic garbage on the campaign
trail.